The one to one initiative is currently sweeping through schools all across the nation, but is it really a good program for schools? In this post I will offer three reasons as to why administrators might want to rethink going one to one.
1) The benefit does not outweigh the cost
Money is a part of every decision in schools these days. Each kid has a dollar sign hanging above their head as they walk the halls. Every new program, club, activity, and initiative costs districts money. One to one programs are extremely expensive for schools districts. Is supplying every single student with a device really worth the financial burden that the school takes on? It may be a much more financially sound decision to provide each classroom with a class set of devices or even to become a BYOD school.
2) Too much emphasis on the device
Many administrators view one to one devices as an instant way to magically create a new school atmosphere that is progressive and adaptive to 21st century learning. But the truth of the matter is that there is too much emphasis placed on the devices and not enough emphasis placed on the pedagogy; devices themselves will NOT change a thing if there is not a fundamental change in the culture of learning at the school. The change starts with the teachers, not the devices.
3) Technology is not a "one size fits all"
Giving the same technological device to a science class and an English class just simply does not make sense. Learners in the science classroom need a more hands-on, interactive approach that something like a tablet would lend itself to. English teachers need devices that can be used to type, share, and edit documents. There is a fundamental difference to what type of technology works in what class. One to one initiatives go against the needs of learners in different classrooms.
Thanks for reading. Please check out the links below for more resources and analysis on one to one environments.
http://novemberlearning.com/educational-resources-for-educators/teaching-and-learning-articles/why-schools-must-move-beyond-one-to-one-computing/
http://www.districtadministration.com/article/are-one-one-laptop-programs-worth-investment
http://www.ascd.org/publications/educational_leadership/feb11/vol68/num05/One-to-One_Laptop_Programs_Are_No_Silver_Bullet.aspx